Suntup Editions - All Books

[sholloman81]

On a completely different note than Gaiman, that Farris book is stinking stunning. I just unboxed mine today and I was very impressed with it. It's expensive, but such a great presentation.

So jealous of you grabbing the Farris book.  Trying to talk myself into it as I really want a copy but the angel on my other shoulder keeps reminding me of a few upcoming books that I need to budget for as well as the Christmas holidays.

[Sock Monkey]

I'm of a similar mind, that while I had some initial (if moderate) interest a couple years ago to request to be added to the pre-order list, my situation at the immediate moment -- especially after a hefty Centipede purchase (Farris) back-to-back with a Thunderstorm purchase (Strand) less than a week ago -- doesn't really support that kind of $$$ output, particularly for a book that I didn't particularly enjoy when I read it a decade (?) or so ago. Gaiman's CORALINE is a special movie for our family, but I can't really count myself a fan of his work beyond that one (and I've actually never read the source book, though I do own the Subterranean and Lyra limited editions of it), so there's no impetus there, either. So between a tight budget, an unsatisfying reading experience, and not a Gaiman fan per se, it's hard to justify this one, other than the usual dose of FOMO...and given that all my books are still in their moving boxes and will likely stay that way for several more months, even that compulsion is tempered a bit, since the book wouldn't even be able to be shelved and displayed properly for a good while.

On a completely different note than Gaiman, that Farris book is stinking stunning. I just unboxed mine today and I was very impressed with it. It's expensive, but such a great presentation.

[RonClinton]

I'm of a similar mind, that while I had some initial (if moderate) interest a couple years ago to request to be added to the pre-order list, my situation at the immediate moment -- especially after a hefty Centipede purchase (Farris) back-to-back with a Thunderstorm purchase (Strand) less than a week ago -- doesn't really support that kind of $$$ output, particularly for a book that I didn't particularly enjoy when I read it a decade (?) or so ago. Gaiman's CORALINE is a special movie for our family, but I can't really count myself a fan of his work beyond that one (and I've actually never read the source book, though I do own the Subterranean and Lyra limited editions of it), so there's no impetus there, either. So between a tight budget, an unsatisfying reading experience, and not a Gaiman fan per se, it's hard to justify this one, other than the usual dose of FOMO...and given that all my books are still in their moving boxes and will likely stay that way for several more months, even that compulsion is tempered a bit, since the book wouldn't even be able to be shelved and displayed properly for a good while.

[Sock Monkey]

Anyone picking-up American Gods? I had signed up for the pre-order earlier this year but think I'm going to pass due to already having a different version, the price point, and there being a few other upcoming releases that I need to budget for. I Wonder if this one will sell out and how quickly? Suntup's timing is also a bit unfortunate due to Gaiman's recent legal issues.

I'm tempted as I do really enjoy Gaiman's work. Even if it doesn't always stick the landing, I always enjoy reading his prose. However, the price point is a sticking point for me. If money wasn't an option, then I'd probably be scrambling for a copy, but as it stands, I just don't think the budget will be that forgiving. I am also not a huge fan of the dustjacket art on the Classic Edition so that makes it easier for me. That Limited, though, is freaking gorgeous.

As far as Gaiman's legal issues, I'm also not easily put off by things like this and I'm also of the mindset that allegations are just that until proven otherwise. I don't think that his legal issues will have any impact on whether or not Suntup's edition sells out or not. I am of the mindset that this will sell out rather quickly. At $300 and with a print run of 1250, I don't see the Classic Edition increasing dramatically on the aftermarket. Frankly, I've seen the prices on some Suntup editions soften quite a bit. Though I think that is indicative of the overall market right now.

[sholloman81]

Easy pass for me. I'm in the minority that doesn't enjoy his writing.

On the other note I've never been put off by accusations or even convictions. If something speaks to me it does.

Yeah, I'm pretty much the same. I don't judge a piece of art any differently even if the artist is a slimeball. I just wonder if his issues might put off a random or casual buyer.  Of course, I doubt there is such a thing at Suntup's $300 minimum price point for this book.  

[Ben Staad]

Easy pass for me. I'm in the minority that doesn't enjoy his writing.

On the other note I've never been put off by accusations or even convictions. If something speaks to me it does.

Anyone picking-up American Gods? I had signed up for the pre-order earlier this year but think I'm going to pass due to already having a different version, the price point, and there being a few other upcoming releases that I need to budget for. I Wonder if this one will sell out and how quickly? Suntup's timing is also a bit unfortunate due to Gaiman's recent legal issues.

[sholloman81]

Anyone picking-up American Gods? I had signed up for the pre-order earlier this year but think I'm going to pass due to already having a different version, the price point, and there being a few other upcoming releases that I need to budget for. I Wonder if this one will sell out and how quickly? Suntup's timing is also a bit unfortunate due to Gaiman's recent legal issues.

[goathunter]

Binkley's art is a lot better than I expected, having previously just seen what's on his website. I hated Ho's work on The Border and Swan Song, so I was really happy to see that he wasn't used for the Suntup. Then again, his work doesn't seem like a match for Suntup for any book.

[jeffingoff]

I'm more excited about Boy's Life than Swan Song, but I did pick up the numbered edition. Partly to keep rights for American Gods, but I'm still excited. I don't mind the artwork, but I do prefer David Ho's artwork from the Sub Press edition.

I'm going to be the odd one out here and vote for Binkley over Ho for Swan Song. I think Ho did a spectacular job for the SubPress edition. I have it on my shelf and wouldn't trade it for anything. But the Binkley art has a little more magic to it. A dark tweak on reality and the choice to make the dust jacket an image of hope and rebirth is a very interesting one to me. The darkness and destruction is the struggle but not the point. But visual art is even more subjective than the written word and I wouldn't strongly argue my point against those who prefer Ho because you're not wrong.

That said, I'll be thrilled to have both the Suntup and SubPress editions.

[Splync]

I'm more excited about Boy's Life than Swan Song, but I did pick up the numbered edition. Partly to keep rights for American Gods, but I'm still excited. I don't mind the artwork, but I do prefer David Ho's artwork from the Sub Press edition.

[Chuggers]

I agree, considering I paid almost $20 for a mass market pb copy over the summer, I would've absolutely jumped on this release if I cared for the artwork. 

[RonClinton]

I think SubPress had much better artwork on both Swan Song and Boy's life.

I agree. There’s a certain levity to much of the Suntup art in both books — especially SWAN SONG — that doesn’t quite click with me. I’d rank the SWAN SONG editions:
Subterranean,
Dark Harvest,
Suntup.

[bsaenz24]

I think SubPress had much better artwork on both Swan Song and Boy's life.

[RonClinton]

Similar to their announcement of BOY'S LIFE, I have the oversized slipcased Subterranean edition of SWAN SONG, which I like quite a bit. While SWAN SONG is a favorite, I just can't justify the price tags for an "bonus" copy to put on the shelf. The limited edition is very nice looking, though

Could not say it better myself.

[sholloman81]

Similar to their announcement of BOY'S LIFE, I have the oversized slipcased Subterranean edition of SWAN SONG, which I like quite a bit. While SWAN SONG is a favorite, I just can't justify the price tags for an "bonus" copy to put on the shelf. The limited edition is very nice looking, though, and if I was in the market, that would be the edition I would want.

My sentiments exactly! I'm staying strong and sticking with my SubPress copy.