All Things Earthling Publications

[Sock Monkey]

Well...the new Earthling book is Dune. No offense to Paul at Earthling at all, but I found the announcement to be a little underwhelming considering that we just got the Centipede edition like a year and a half ago. I was also WAY off on the price as it is a whopping $650 (which, to be fair, was in the same realm of the Centipede edition). Since I already have a very nice edition of the book from Centipede, this would have been a pass for me whatever the price point.

[Splync]

Well...the new Earthling book is Dune. No offense to Paul at Earthling at all, but I found the announcement to be a little underwhelming considering that we just got the Centipede edition like a year and a half ago. I was also WAY off on the price as it is a whopping $650 (which, to be fair, was in the same realm of the Centipede edition). Since I already have a very nice edition of the book from Centipede, this would have been a pass for me whatever the price point.

I bought it because I'd like to see them side by side. My wallet hurts...

[Sock Monkey]

DUNE. $650. Okay, well, given that I'm already doing the Centipede series, that was an easy decision. I'm sure it'll be lovely, though.

I'm curious what impact, if any, this new edition will have on the aftermarket prices of the Centipede edition. I'm thinking not too much because it doesn't seem as I didn't see any indication that Earthling will be doing any more of the books in the series.

And this is not a criticism at Earthling, but really the limited edition market as a whole, I'm not a fan of there being multiple limited editions of the same books being created within a small time frame. I don't disagree that publishers should do the books they are passionate about, I just feel that there are so many other books that have yet to get a limited edition that I just feel like the same well is being tapped over and over again.

[Sock Monkey]

I bought it because I'd like to see them side by side. My wallet hurts...

That's fair and I don't begrudge anyone who picks up the book. I'm sure that the Earthling edition is going to be very nice as Paul does a great job with his books. I'd also love to see pictures if you'd care to post when it arrives. I think I had just gotten myself a little too excited and then felt rather deflated once I read the announcement.

For curiosity's sake, do you plan on keeping both editions or are you going to keep whichever one you like the best? My budget and space never allows me to buy multiple editions of a title. However, I am tempted to break this rule if there is a deluxe edition of Centipede's Ghost Story.

[Dave1442397]

DUNE. $650. Okay, well, given that I'm already doing the Centipede series, that was an easy decision. I'm sure it'll be lovely, though.

Yeah, same here. I didn't get home until 12:30, and was surprised that they weren't sold out already. It looks nice, but I'm already committed to the CP editions.

[Splync]

For curiosity's sake, do you plan on keeping both editions or are you going to keep whichever one you like the best? My budget and space never allows me to buy multiple editions of a title. However, I am tempted to break this rule if there is a deluxe edition of Centipede's Ghost Story.

In a perfect world, I'd keep both editions.

 It's more likely that it'll keep whichever edition I prefer more. But I'll try to keep them together in my book hoard for as long as I can.

[RonClinton]

I'm curious what impact, if any, this new edition will have on the aftermarket prices of the Centipede edition. I'm thinking not too much because it doesn't seem as I didn't see any indication that Earthling will be doing any more of the books in the series.

And this is not a criticism at Earthling, but really the limited edition market as a whole, I'm not a fan of there being multiple limited editions of the same books being created within a small time frame. I don't disagree that publishers should do the books they are passionate about, I just feel that there are so many other books that have yet to get a limited edition that I just feel like the same well is being tapped over and over again.

--------------------

My budget and space never allows me to buy multiple editions of a title. However, I am tempted to break this rule if there is a deluxe edition of Centipede's Ghost Story.

I do agree that as a collector it's a bit disappointing when the same book is done back-to-back, so to speak, by different small-press publishers, when there are so many wonderful books out there waiting their turn. But ultimately the market will prove whether or not the choice is sound...copies still remain 90 minutes after offering, but I suspect it'll be sold out by day's (or perhaps week's) end. Or perhaps not, hard to say. I hope it does sell see a quick sell-out...Paul's a great guy, and deserves every bit of success he gets.

As far as impacting the value of the Centipede edition, I don't think it'll have too much...first, as you say, it looks like this is a one-off and not a series set like Centipede, which inherently helps maintain the value of the first Centipede volume as an indispensable part of the set, and, two, I do think, due to higher production values and the fact that it was the first published of the two, that the Centipede will still be seen as The One to Have, much in the same way that the availability of the Folio Society edition has had little to no impact on the desirability and aftermarket value of the Centipede edition. I'm not comparing the Folio mid-grade edition to Earthling's high-end production, of course, but it's still a matter of perceived return-on-investment, especially with Centipede's established, proven reputation as a premium publisher in the marketplace...that type of high-end publishing is something that Earthling is just beginning to dabble in with its last couple of books (INSPECTION and DUNE) in an otherwise couple of decades of sub-$100 books, so it may be a bit of leap for collectors to invest $650 in a volume in a type of book that has no track history from the publisher, even though I have no doubt Paul will hit it out of the park.

As far as GHOST STORY, not sure about that one for me...I have the signed/#d HC from Hill House, and that may just have to suffice, as I've tried to draw a red-line on multiple volumes of the same book. But we'll see...that's going to be a tough one to pass on.

[Chuggers]

I was stunned when I opened the email this afternoon and saw DUNE listed there. Stunned....and a little relieved.

[Sock Monkey]

I was stunned when I opened the email this afternoon and saw DUNE listed there. Stunned....and a little relieved.

After I was a little bummed about the announcement, I found some feelings of relief nestled within. Dropping $650 today would have been really hard to do.

[Sock Monkey]

I do agree that as a collector it's a bit disappointing when the same book is done back-to-back, so to speak, by different small-press publishers, when there are so many wonderful books out there waiting their turn. But ultimately the market will prove whether or not the choice is sound...copies still remain 90 minutes after offering, but I suspect it'll be sold out by day's (or perhaps week's) end. Or perhaps not, hard to say. I hope it does sell see a quick sell-out...Paul's a great guy, and deserves every bit of success he gets.

As far as impacting the value of the Centipede edition, I don't think it'll have too much...first, as you say, it looks like this is a one-off and not a series set like Centipede, which inherently helps maintain the value of the first Centipede volume as an indispensable part of the set, and, two, I do think, due to higher production values and the fact that it was the first published of the two, that the Centipede will still be seen as The One to Have, much in the same way that the availability of the Folio Society edition has had little to no impact on the desirability and aftermarket value of the Centipede edition. I'm not comparing the Folio mid-grade edition to Earthling's high-end production, of course, but it's still a matter of perceived return-on-investment, especially with Centipede's established, proven reputation as a premium publisher in the marketplace...that type of high-end publishing is something that Earthling is just beginning to dabble in with its last couple of books (INSPECTION and DUNE) in an otherwise couple of decades of sub-$100 books, so it may be a bit of leap for collectors to invest $650 in a volume in a type of book that has no track history from the publisher, even though I have no doubt Paul will hit it out of the park.

As far as GHOST STORY, not sure about that one for me...I have the signed/#d HC from Hill House, and that may just have to suffice, as I've tried to draw a red-line on multiple volumes of the same book. But we'll see...that's going to be a tough one to pass on.

Your thoughts about the lack of impact on the Centipede version seems sound to me. I don't like to think about those things too much in my collecting, but it is always in interesting facet of the hobby.

[Scoogs]

I wasn't even familiar with Earthling Publications before yesterday, so this was a surprise to me.

Counting Folio, this is the third limited edition of Dune in what, 1.5-2 years? That's a little much, but given my Dune collection, it's probably no surprise that I ordered one.
Hoping that I like the artwork more when I see the actual book.

Still available after more than 24 hours, so maybe there is some market fatigue.
Honestly, I prefer that over watching them sellout in 20 minutes and end up on eBay a half hour later.

[TacomaDiver]

Your point stands, but the Folio edition came out about six years ago, unless they've done a new version of the one that came out then.

[Splync]

Your point stands, but the Folio edition came out about six years ago, unless they've done a new version of the one that came out then.

They did a limited edition within the last few years. It was essentially the standard edition with a different binding and a pretty cool traycase.

[Scoogs]

Splync, I just found your Youtube channel yesterday. Good stuff.

[Sock Monkey]

I wasn't even familiar with Earthling Publications before yesterday, so this was a surprise to me.

Counting Folio, this is the third limited edition of Dune in what, 1.5-2 years? That's a little much, but given my Dune collection, it's probably no surprise that I ordered one.
Hoping that I like the artwork more when I see the actual book.

Still available after more than 24 hours, so maybe there is some market fatigue.
Honestly, I prefer that over watching them sellout in 20 minutes and end up on eBay a half hour later.

Well, you are in for some good times with just finding out about Earthling. I really like their books and, for the most part, they are pretty affordable. Their Halloween series is a lot of fun.

I agree with your statement about rather seeing sales trickle out for Earthling's Dune instead of seeing it sell out to flippers. I do not have a problem with people reselling books as I do it myself from time to time, but some of the examples of excessive flipping always bums me out a little.