Originally posted by sholloman81
View Post
I don't even really know where to start with why it didn't work for me. Generally uninteresting characters (save for the first, I don't know, 50 pages or so, that were, in fact, very promising); an initially intriguing presentation construct that didn't work to entertain or enlighten or chill but rather to, for me, kind of annoy and distract; a plot that developed veerryyy slowly so that only by the halfway point of the book was there some sort of sense where the story might be heading; and so on. I'm really disappointed in my experience as this was a book I had been really looking forward to, given my love for Tremblay's work, but it just did not work for me in any way. I'm half-tempted to grab the SST anyhow and see if a re-read a year (?) from now, or whenever it releases, changes my perspective as, frankly, I'm surprised at my reaction to it -- so maybe it's me, not the book? -- but, eh, I probably won't...there are issues here that even objectively I can see are contrary to the way I like to see stories presented. To be fair, though, I have read positive reviews of it among the mixed reaction, so some folks clearly enjoyed it...I wish I was one of them, I truly do. But this one-off bad experience hasn't shaken my confidence in Tremblay's ability to entertain me...he's built up too much goodwill with me with his backlist for that. I'm looking forward to his new short-story collection next year, and whatever else he may have coming down the pike.
Comment