Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Rule Clairification

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • johnpeters
    replied
    Thanks for the clarification. And I think splitting them into groups was definitely the right choice. Unfortunately, you could end up with the top two total voter-getters in one group, but still, that's definitely the lesser of two evils. I don't believe there's any way I could have read them all, but now I can read all in any group in which I wish to vote, and then I can definitely find time to read the 11 sub-winners. So, yeah, that was a smart move in my humble opinion.

    Leave a comment:


  • Steven Cox
    replied
    Hi Dan.
    Just wanted to say that as far as I'm concerned, I think that you and all the guys at CD are doing a great job. In particular, this short story competition has been a terrific opportunity for all budding authors, both for the chance to submit our own work and enjoy the talents of others. Sadly, there's always one or two who have got a downer on things in general and the best thing to do is treat their often unfounded criticisms with the contempt they deserve - ban and bin! But like a couple have said before me, I bet the "discussion" between you would make a riveting read...
    By the way, whilst I'm here, a big thank you to Draven for taking the trouble to post his support for my story. A man of fine taste, clearly - or perhaps questionably?
    Keen up the good work Dan, so too all your CD buddies.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dan Hocker
    replied
    Umm I think it's the 22nd, it should say on the actual polls when they end, as they will close automatically. Only one story from each group will move to the final round of voting. The goal is to keep the final vote focused and not so spread out. This way we can take a more detailed comparison between the better stories as I know the decision is going to be tough for a lot of people.

    Leave a comment:


  • douglasi
    replied
    Originally posted by Dan Hocker View Post
    This actually wasn't something accounted for in the rules, mostly because we where not expecting this kind of response to the contest. The voting solution is something Brian and I thought up a couple of days before the window for entering was closed. The winners of the first round of stories will move onto another round of voting, and then the top 3 in that final round will be in the chapbook.

    Edit: We thought this was a much better solution than putting all the stories in one vote and hoping everyone had time to read all of them and was able to pick out the one they thought was the single best out of them. This way people don't have to narrow their overall choice down till the final vote.

    So the first round will be open until the 22nd? And the second round of voting will be the final round? I am also wondering if there will only be one winner from each group or are you just taking those stories with the most votes. I am still a little confused I guess, Sorry!

    Leave a comment:


  • Dan Hocker
    replied
    Originally posted by johnpeters View Post
    I have a question regarding the rules. And yes, I did read the rules -- very clear and concise, I thought -- but I'm curious. With the contest entries split into 10 groups, is this now set up so that each group winner advances to another round of voting, or will it be the top three vote getters regardless of grouping? In other words, would it be conceivable to see two of the top three, or even all three, come from the same group?

    Thanks, and I add my voice to the others, nice forum. I'll be visiting here long after the contest concludes.
    This actually wasn't something accounted for in the rules, mostly because we where not expecting this kind of response to the contest. The voting solution is something Brian and I thought up a couple of days before the window for entering was closed. The winners of the first round of stories will move onto another round of voting, and then the top 3 in that final round will be in the chapbook.

    Edit: We thought this was a much better solution than putting all the stories in one vote and hoping everyone had time to read all of them and was able to pick out the one they thought was the single best out of them. This way people don't have to narrow their overall choice down till the final vote.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dan Hocker
    replied
    Originally posted by Untitled View Post
    So, if I've published one short story, I'm no longer an amateur? I'm a professional? Sweet! At least, that's what that guy's definition appears to be. But seriously, I always interpreted "professional" to mean "gets paid to do it for a living." Granted, if a bestselling author who happened to not have been published at CD entered the contest, I think a few folks would call SHENANIGANS!, but it doesn't look like the folks here are claiming to make house payments with their fiction. I'm sure that's the dream of many, however, which is wonderful, and more power to them!
    This was kinda my take on the meaning of "professional" as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • Untitled
    replied
    So, if I've published one short story, I'm no longer an amateur? I'm a professional? Sweet! At least, that's what that guy's definition appears to be. But seriously, I always interpreted "professional" to mean "gets paid to do it for a living." Granted, if a bestselling author who happened to not have been published at CD entered the contest, I think a few folks would call SHENANIGANS!, but it doesn't look like the folks here are claiming to make house payments with their fiction. I'm sure that's the dream of many, however, which is wonderful, and more power to them!

    Leave a comment:


  • johnpeters
    replied
    I have a question regarding the rules. And yes, I did read the rules -- very clear and concise, I thought -- but I'm curious. With the contest entries split into 10 groups, is this now set up so that each group winner advances to another round of voting, or will it be the top three vote getters regardless of grouping? In other words, would it be conceivable to see two of the top three, or even all three, come from the same group?

    Thanks, and I add my voice to the others, nice forum. I'll be visiting here long after the contest concludes.

    Leave a comment:


  • peteOcha
    replied
    Ahh, good ol' forum drama. This forum delivers!

    Leave a comment:


  • Dan Hocker
    replied
    Originally posted by jester05jk View Post
    How long has the site been up, like a month and already a banishment? Nice.
    Before the site was even publicly announced I had 4 bans racked up from spam bots.... lol.

    Leave a comment:


  • Antmusic
    replied
    There have been some spammers that have been banned too, but so quickly that you probably didn't notice.

    Leave a comment:


  • jester05jk
    replied
    How long has the site been up, like a month and already a banishment? Nice.

    Leave a comment:


  • Draven Ames
    replied
    I agree completely. Thank you for the great work, Dan.

    Leave a comment:


  • hamount
    replied
    Yeah, I have to agree, and I'd love to see that discussion too. It'd make for an entertaining read.

    Leave a comment:


  • C.W. LaSart
    replied
    You have done an excellent job of policing the forum. There will always be those who feel they are getting a raw deal-just a product of the times. I would give my left foot to see that discussion though! Haha! I bet it got ugly.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X