If this were a decision on a 6 -figure print run, I'd say let the cover stand; but for a limited run like this, I like the move. Part of what make a book collectible is the art, so you might as well show it off. Thanks for listening, Brian.
I agree with everyone else, Thanks Brian! Of course I don't really have a say in this as I didn't order a copy however I think it's great how CD responded to the feedback in this thread.
WTF?!?!? Is this some kind of democracy??? What happened to the good ole days of "Here's the cover, now shut your cake hold and LIKE IT!!!" You're getting soft Brian! LOL!
I am honestly starting to think we picked the last option before, because we'd seen about 20 different versions of the other design. Then the design a lot of you ended up not like came along, and I think we where so tired of looking at the layouts, we kinda just said "Lets go for this one"....
Not really lazy, more like tunnel vision. When you look at so many variations of what's basically the same thing, they all blurr together and start to look the same. Maybe I'll post some examples of the different versions we looked at to give you an idea.
Not really lazy, more like tunnel vision. When you look at so many variations of what's basically the same thing, they all blurr together and start to look the same. Maybe I'll post some examples of the different versions we looked at to give you an idea.
I'd like to see some of them, Dan. That's a pretty good idea!
Not really lazy, more like tunnel vision. When you look at so many variations of what's basically the same thing, they all blurr together and start to look the same. Maybe I'll post some examples of the different versions we looked at to give you an idea.
We'd probably need to post the whole set, just so you can see how frustrating it gets around image #20. "Well, this one has a little more orange to it, and this one has a slightly larger font, etc." After a while, they all start to look the same. Plus, we need to get 5 people at the office to basically agree, and often we need the approval of the agent and the author (who have only seen and thought about trade hardcovers their whole lives), and sometimes the original publisher... ugh. I'll ask Gail if she's okay with us posting this whole set. As the designer, we'd want her permission first.
By the way, we had the same trouble with Full Dark, No Stars -- only for that one, we had a pretty good idea WHERE we wanted to go after seeing the first round of options, it just took a while to get there:
By the way, we had the same trouble with Full Dark, No Stars -- only for that one, we had a pretty good idea WHERE we wanted to go after seeing the first round of options, it just took a while to get there:
It's amazing how such small changes alter the entire look. Before you posted these, I used to think that you just got the art and put a good logo on and went, but, wow, what a lot goes into getting just the right look and tone.
"Dance until your feet hurt. Sing until your lungs hurt. Act until you're William Hurt." - Phil Dunphy ("Modern Family"), from Phil's-osophy.
Comment