Leaving books with or without slipcases in the publishers shrink-wrap. Do or Don't??

[Brian861]

Try to clean it up with some Goo Gone or similar cleaning product.

Apprehensive about that I'll admit. Might give it a go all the same though.

[Dan Hocker]

That book is a matte finish right? That can happen with matte finish stuff, most likely is just dirt / dust from the manufacturing plant. It should just rub off pretty easily.

[slayn666]

Try to clean it up with some Goo Gone or similar cleaning product.

[Brian861]

The shrink-wrap was only in contact with the slipcase and it's mint. Curious to know if other copies had this same issue. And of course I have no idea of the storage conditions before it was sent to me. Oh well. Is what it is now.

[Martin]

Discovered this today when I removed the shrink-wrap from it. The slipcase is perfectly clean on the inside but both covers of the book have what appear to be spots. There really isn't any texture to the spots so I don't think it's caused from moisture. Any clues? Thanks

[ATTACH=CONFIG]17140[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]17141[/ATTACH]

I would guess it is a staining from the shrinkwrap being in contact with the book surface. Just a guess though.

[mhatchett]

I've always felt that shrink wrap is the devil. books need air, like all living things lol!

[Brian861]

Discovered this today when I removed the shrink-wrap from it. The slipcase is perfectly clean on the inside but both covers of the book have what appear to be spots. There really isn't any texture to the spots so I don't think it's caused from moisture. Any clues? Thanks

Doctor Sleep Damage 1.jpgDoctor Sleep Damage 2.jpg

[slayn666]

Just a little insight into how this stuff works. Assuming Sub Press does some things in a similar fashion to how we do them, they don't DJ the books themselves, that's done at the manufacturing facility. From that point one of three things (or a combination of them) is probably happening. One, the books aren't being inspected very closely and damaged DJ's slip through. This can happen pretty easily, especially if you're in a hurry. Two, someone is putting them in the slipcases in a fashion that damages the DJ. Three, the books are pre-numbered and the manufacturer is slipcasesing the books at the plant. In this last instance Sub Press would never even see the DJ. I seriously doubt anyone is doing it knowingly. More likely than not they may have some new help in there warehouse, and it's really easy for stuff like that to slip through, especially when working with new employees.

Thanks for the insights, Dan. Based on where the damage is located, I suspect the first thing you mentioned is the culprit. Luckily, Bill is a cool guy and is going to send me a replacement (though this introduces its own flavor of irritation...).

[Brian861]

Really appreciate all the replies guys. All the info has been most helpful. Learned some key "do's and dont's" and things to look for.

[Dan Hocker]

Speaking of other publishers and slipcases, I've had some issues with Sub Press books arriving with damaged dust jackets, even when the book is protected by the slipcase. That tells me that they are knowingly putting damaged dust jackets on their high-end books, because I'm not talking about a minor rub that no one will ever see, I'm talking about major creases and the like.

Just a little insight into how this stuff works. Assuming Sub Press does some things in a similar fashion to how we do them, they don't DJ the books themselves, that's done at the manufacturing facility. From that point one of three things (or a combination of them) is probably happening. One, the books aren't being inspected very closely and damaged DJ's slip through. This can happen pretty easily, especially if you're in a hurry. Two, someone is putting them in the slipcases in a fashion that damages the DJ. Three, the books are pre-numbered and the manufacturer is slipcasesing the books at the plant. In this last instance Sub Press would never even see the DJ. I seriously doubt anyone is doing it knowingly. More likely than not they may have some new help in there warehouse, and it's really easy for stuff like that to slip through, especially when working with new employees.

[slayn666]

Speaking of other publishers and slipcases, I've had some issues with SubPress books arriving with damaged dust jackets, even when the book is protected by the slipcase. That tells me that they are knowingly putting damaged dust jackets on their high-end books, because I'm not talking about a minor rub that no one will ever see, I'm talking about major creases and the like.

[drain74]

Another point that I have seen in a forum at some point is that with the shrink-wrap left on it can be hard to tell if the book is damaged in any way. Maybe even missing the signature page.

A book I received from another publisher (shrink-wrapped in a slipcase) looked fine as received. The slipcase was fine however there were marks on the back of the dust-jacket that were indented into the book. (I was luck enough to receive a replacement book).

[Martin]

I do have a few slipcased books that are too tight a fit to add a Brodart cover. I actually must be extra careful removing them from the slipcase due to the tightness. The traycased books I have all have enough room to allow for covers.

[Brian861]

I protect with Brodart all books that are not traycased or slipcased. Slipcased is debatable, and I wonder if the spine might fade comparatively to the front and back over time even in low light conditions. But it's likely not always feasible to protect a slipcased book due to fit and the additional bulk of the plastic.

Without slipcases or traycases I'd 100% recommend protecting with an archival cover. It's not only protection from time and light you're getting, but also enhanced durability in handling. When you've got a non-reading buddy over admiring your collection, hand him a Brodart protected book you love and a non-protected one and see which one makes you nervous.

The phrase, "You can look but don't touch" comes to mind . I plan on slipcasing all my collectables for those not included with the purchase. Traycases would have to be a step above that I'd think. I've read of that issue as well with the Brodart not wanting to fit back into the slipcase. I currently don't own any traycased volumes so not sure if that would allow for a better fit with the Brodart or not. I'm sure someone here would know no doubt.

[bugen]

I protect with Brodart all books that are not traycased or slipcased. Slipcased is debatable, and I wonder if the spine might fade comparatively to the front and back over time even in low light conditions. But it's likely not always feasible to protect a slipcased book due to fit and the additional bulk of the plastic.

Without slipcases or traycases I'd 100% recommend protecting with an archival cover. It's not only protection from time and light you're getting, but also enhanced durability in handling. When you've got a non-reading buddy over admiring your collection, hand him a Brodart protected book you love and a non-protected one and see which one makes you nervous.